• Train Travel
  • Urban Rail Transit
  • Where To Stay

Nomadic Notes

Travel blog and weekly travel newsletter

  • Blog
  • Travel Newsletter

50 years of Lonely Planet: Revisiting Across Asia on the cheap in Thailand

June 15, 2023 By James Clark 9 Comments

50 years of Lonely Planet: Revisiting Across Asia on the cheap in Thailand

It’s been 50 years since the publication of the original guide book that launched Lonely Planet.

Across Asia on the Cheap was published in 1973 by Tony and Maureen Wheeler after overlanding from London to Australia. The publication of the guide book has become the stuff of legend. They typed and stapled the guidebook on their kitchen table, and they sold 1500 copies within a week.

The book sold for $1.80 AUD, so that is $2,700 AUD. Working that figure out today, 1 AUD in June 1973 was 1.4155 USD, so 1.8 AUD = 2.55 USD. Using an inflation calculator, that works out to $17.47 USD in 2023 money.

$17.47 x 1500 = $26,205 USD in 2023 money.

The immediate popularity was incentive enough to do it again, and two years later South-East Asia on a Shoestring was published. Southeast Asia on a Shoestring is still sold today, and copies of “The Yellow Bible” can be found in hostels and guesthouses across the region.

I have a copy buried in storage somewhere so I couldn’t take a photo for this article. By pure chance I moved to a new place when I was writing this article, and there is a copy on the shelf.

Lonely Planet ornament

It is displayed here like a collected ornament, a curio from another era, like your grandfather’s phonograph record player that no longer has a purpose (or if you are a young person, your grandfather’s Walkman).

This is the 2004 edition with 972 pages. I think mine was from 2006, and it has the same chonky heft to it as this one.

Southeast Asia on a Shoestring 2004

Can you believe that it wasn’t that long ago when we used to have these in our bags.

So I put a 972-page guidebook in my backpack, which was the style at the time

In a case of unbelievably good timing, the Wheelers sold Lonely Planet to the BBC in 2007, and they sold their remaining stake in 2011.

Across Asia on the Cheap was re-released on PDF and Kindle in 2013 when Lonely Planet turned 40, and I wrote a review about this amazing historical archive of a bygone era.

Lonely Planet is turning 50 this year and I happen to be in Thailand at this time, so I thought I would go through the Thailand section to see what has changed.

Across Asia on the Cheap – Thailand (1973)

Across Asia on the Cheap has 94 pages, of which 4 pages is dedicated to Thailand. Of that, there is about a page dedicated to things to see. It gives the most amount of printed real estate to Wat Po (about 1 paragraph) and mentions the mother of pearl inlaid soles on the reclining Buddha.

Wat Po Bangkok
[Pretty sure this view has not changed in 50 years.]

Other temple mentions include Wat Phra Keo (the temple of the emerald Buddha), Wat Arun, and Wat Benchamborpit across the road from Dusit Zoo (which closed in 2018).

The guide also mentions Bangkok’s prime attraction of the floating market as being “virtually tourists only”. It doesn’t say which market in particular, but I have heard the refrain of the floating markets being too touristy ever since I have been coming to Thailand. Perhaps this is a long-held tradition to gripe about tourists. I imagine sailors disembarking on the docks of the Chao Phraya River in the 1930s complaining about the tourists as well.

The only other places that are mentioned are Chiang Mai, Ayuthya, the bridge over the river Kwai, Nakorn Pathom, and an elephant round up in Surin.

Accommodation

The Thailand section includes a grand total of 4 hotel recommendations for the entire country, all of which are in Bangkok. I was surprised to find that 3 of the 4 are still in operation.

The first listing is for Thai Song Greet with a description you wouldn’t see in a 2023 guide book:

“Next to the railway station is Thai Song Greet, cheap at 30 bahts a double, but incredibly noisy from the traffic outside, The good restaurant downstairs is the Bangkok bottleneck point for overlanders, Efforts may be made to pad your bill out (if you are male this is) with local talent, beware — Bangkok has developed some heavy breeds of VD.”

This guesthouse has closed down, but I found this great travellers recollection from 1977. There are also some photos from Old Bangkok.

Nomadic Notes - Travel photos: 2023 &emdash; thai-song-greet-1980
[Thai Song Greet Hotel 1980 from oldbangkok.com.]

The next listing is Starlight Hotel:

“Rather better accommodation is the Starlight Hotel at Soi 22 Sukumvit — Soi 22 is the 22nd road off the Sukumvit road, Air conditioning and a private bathroom for 40 bahts is reasonable, but during the rush hour it can be a long ride from the centre, Buses are so cheap that transportation in and out is no financial problem.”

I wasn’t familiar with Starlight Hotel but I knew the location so I went to look for it. It was amusing to read that it was located “a long ride from the centre”. Sukhumvit 22 is now near what is arguably the new city centre at Asok.

Sukhumvit 22
[Sukhumvit 22]

Starlight 22 is down an alley lined with girlie bars.

Starlight 22 Alley

Starlight 22 is at the end of the alley, and behind it is the gargantuan Emsphere Mall project.

Starlight 22

Room rates start at 400 THB, so it is still a bargain in today’s money. In keeping with the old days, this hotel is not listed on any booking sites so you have to walk in or book in advance.

Starlight room rates
[Starlight room rates.]

The Atlanta gets a brief mention, and it has been trading off this claim to fame ever since. From the guide:

“The Atlanta at Soi 2 Sukumvit is about the same level although we hear that bad scenes take place there with the cops on occasion, Around the railway station area are a number of other cheap hotels.”

The Atlanta is right down the end of a dead-end street, so there is very little traffic.

Atlanta Hotel

I have never seen the building but I have seen the entrance sign “Sex Tourists Not Welcome” posted online before.

Atlanta entrance

I was pleasantly surprised to see the foyer decked out in art deco style. The hotel celebrated its 70th anniversary last year, and the hotel has a website looks like it is about to celebrate it 20th anniversary, giving me some sweet HTML coding nostalgia.

Atlanta foyer

Interesting to note that it isn’t listed on online booking sites either. One of the things about being listed in Lonely Planet was that if you got listed you were guaranteed a steady stream of walk-in traffic. You would never need to advertise if you were listed in the Lonely Planet. The name of The Atlanta must be so well known that they can fill their rooms without relying on booking agents.

Here is another review from Travelfish to get an idea of it.

The last hotel that is still running is The Malaysia:

“We spent one night in quite a different class of accommodation in Bangkok. The Malaysia, a very flash looking place, was doing some special deal whereby you could have the first night at 40 bahts and thereafter at 60. Our theory was that with Viet Nam R and R business disappearing a lot of Bangkok hotels are looking hard in other directions for business.”

I stayed here after reading that it was listed, and here the review of my stay.

Malaysia Hotel - Bangkok
[The Malaysia Hotel in 2023.]

The hotel has been renovated again since I was there, and I have met other people who have stayed there or know about it.

The hotel is near Soi Ngam Dupli, which ended up becoming the backpacker street of Bangkok (before Khao San Road was the backpacker street). I am wondering if it became the backpacker street on the strength of the Malaysia Hotel listing. Did backpackers turn up to The Malaysia to find it solidly booked out, thus guesthouses started springing up around it to catch the overspill?

One person who would know the answer to this is Joe Cummings, who was the author of the first individual edition of Lonely Planet Thailand. There is a great interview with Joe on the Bangkok Podcast.

For the rest of the country the book just mentions “Elsewhere in Thailand”:

“you can generally find reasonable accommodation for around 20 bahts a double and very good places for 40 to 60 bahts, As in Malaya cheap hotels can be very noisy in the small hours. You can frequently stay free in Buddhist Wats, so long as you’re willing to let the monks practise their English on you. You’ll be doing that anyway!”

Tourists staying for free at wats is now the last thing Thailand wants.

Transport

As someone who writes about transport in Southeast Asia, I found the transport section to be a fascinating insight. Keeping in the spirit of the hippy trail and the simpler times, there are many references to hitchhiking,

There is a reference for getting the Butterworth-Bangkok train for $6 AUD. Unfortunately that train stopped running in 2016, reducing the number of international train in Southeast Asia. It mentions that the Hat Yai to Bangkok train is $5 AUD, so we can use that to compare.

5 AUD in 1973 = 7.08 USD. In 2023 dollars that is about $48.50 USD.

Checking train tickets from Bangkok to Hat Yai in 2023 I found a 2nd Class Sleeper AC ticket for $40 USD, so it is theoretically cheaper to travel by train now than it was 50 years ago. The 1973 guide book doesn’t mention what kind of seat it was, but there definitely wasn’t AC.

Thailand has had train ticket prices frozen on some routes for decades, which is why prices are so cheap (and partly why the State Railways of Thailand are losing so much money). That is a topic I will cover on Future Southeast Asia (subscribe here).

One of the biggest changes to the way people travel is how cheap flying has become. The demise of overland travel as championed by this guide book can be partly attributed to cheap flights.

The guide book lists a sample of flights, and I will use the Bangkok-Calcutta fare as an example.

Asia airfares from 1973

The ticket here is $76 AUD, so that is 107.58 USD in 1973 (in 2023, 76 Dollarydoos gets you just 51 USD 😭 ).

I had a look on Kayak for flights from Bangkok to Kolkata (as it is now known) and here are the sample fares:

Bangkok to Kolkata sample fares

The cheapest fare is about $130 USD, so not really that much different in real terms from 1973. Adjusted for inflation, the 107.38 in 1973 would be $735.04! No wonder that overlanding was so popular if airfares were so expensive.

It gets even more absurd for longhaul flights.

Airfares from Australia in 1973

Sydney to Bangkok is listed as $344 AUD (486.93 USD in 1973). Here is a sample for Sydney to Bangkok flights I found on Skyscanner (in USD).

SYD-BKK airfares in 2023

Even if you add bags and fees to the AirAsia flight, that would be about $250 USD. The Thai Airways flight is cheaper than the 1973 flight. Adjusted for inflation 486.93 USD in 1973 would be about $3,335.33 🤯.

Other countries on the cheap

The guidebook lists countries from Australia to Europe, so I will revisit this guide if I happen to be in other countries this year. Subscribe to get updates of future posts.

Notes

I used this historical currency converter to get 1973 rate.

I used usinflationcalculator.com to get an estimate of 1973 USD in 2023. I present these calculations as ballpark figures for illustration, and it is not presented as precise.

Filed Under: Travel Blog Tagged With: bangkok, guide books, lonely planet, thailand

About James Clark

James Clark is the founder of Nomadic Notes. He has been a digital nomad since 2003, and Nomadic Notes features trip reports, train travel articles, and where to stay guides. He writes about transport and urban development at Future Southeast Asia. Subscribe to the weekly travel newsletter.

Comments

  1. Trevor says

    June 15, 2023 at 9:31 am

    Love the comparisons.

    Greetings from Antananarivo. Using a LP PDF as we speak.

    Reply
    • James Clark says

      June 16, 2023 at 4:31 am

      Thanks, Trevor! Good to see you’re on the road again.

      Reply
  2. Greg Rodgers says

    June 15, 2023 at 1:06 pm

    OK, new Bangkok goal: write in the Scriptorium at the Atlanta Hotel. And you’re right, the only thing missing from their hand-coded website is some animated GIFs! 🙂

    Reply
    • James Clark says

      June 16, 2023 at 4:32 am

      Bring back animated GIFs!

      Reply
  3. Tony Page says

    June 20, 2023 at 1:55 am

    Ah, Thai Son Greet! After flying from Burma to Bangkok this was my introduction to Thailand in my 1977-8 trans-Asia south overland. I remember the chaotic restaurant downstairs with the roaring wok at the back, the wiry cook with his scarred forearms, and the amazing speed at which he worked. My first pad thai too, as I recall.
    I stayed upstairs for a couple of nights in a tiny room doubling as a sweatbox with a shuttered window onto the busy street outside. It may have been funky, but after a bit of research I transferred to the Station Hotel round the corner at Lumpini to luxuriate in a room with two double beds and private facilities for, I think, 80 baht a night.
    Those were the days…

    Reply
    • James Clark says

      June 20, 2023 at 4:25 am

      Thanks Tony, I was hoping someone would comment about Thai Son Greet!

      Reply
      • Tony Page says

        June 20, 2023 at 6:34 am

        Yep, no laptop warriors around in those times, poste restante and notebooks were the order of the day. We didn’t appreciate how lucky we were, no influencers or instagrammers around!

        Reply
  4. Reiner says

    July 3, 2023 at 1:51 pm

    I searched for the Malaysia Hotel in 2018 – and was glad I found it still welcoming guests (stayed there 1979). But what was most astounding: I found that small travel agent J. Travel still existed. I bought my ticket home to Germany there, also in 1979. Unbelievable in the age of online bookings. Indeed, Lonely Planet was a kind of traveler’s bible. Cheers.

    Reply
  5. Supraja Lakshmi N says

    July 28, 2023 at 10:52 am

    I just read your article about the 50 years of Lonely Planet in Thailand, and I wanted to say thank you for writing such an interesting and informative piece. I learned a lot about how the travel guide industry has changed over the decades, and how Thailand has evolved as a tourist destination. I appreciate your article for introducing me to the history and legacy of Lonely Planet, which is one of my favorite travel resources. It made me curious and interested in reading more of their guidebooks, especially the ones that cover other regions of Asia. It also made me excited and eager to visit Thailand someday, and to see for myself how it has changed and remained the same over the years.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Weekly Travel Newsletter

Sign up for the weekly travel newsletter for the latest posts, and a roundup of best travel reads from around the web.
Subscribe For Free Here [No spam, unsubscribe anytime.]

About Nomadic Notes

James Clark from Nomadic Notes

Hi, I’m James Clark, and I've been travelling the world since 2003 while running a location independent travel business. Nomadic Notes is a travel blog featuring travel guides and notes from my travels.

More about me and Nomadic Notes.

Follow Nomadic Notes

Recent Posts

  • Where to stay in Singapore: The best areas and notable hotels
  • Sumatra Railways: A guide to every train line in Sumatra
  • Where to stay in Phan Thiet (Mui Ne): The best beach areas and hotels
  • Notes on Luang Prabang in the new era of the train
  • How to get from Medan to Lake Toba by train and bus
  • Kualanamu Airport Rail Link: The Medan airport train
  • Metro maps of India: High-resolution maps of every metro system in India
  • Where to stay in Bangkok: the best areas and hotels for visitors (2023)
  • Train 261: Bangkok (Hua Lamphong) to Hua Hin by Ordinary Train
  • Subway maps of Japan: High-resolution maps of every metro system in Japan

Where to stay in Southeast Asia

Malaysia
Where to stay in Kuala Lumpur

Singapore
Where to stay in Singapore

Thailand
Where to stay in Bangkok

Vietnam
Where to stay in Da Nang
Where to stay in Hanoi
Where to stay in Ho Chi Minh City

Southeast Asia Rail Travel

Southeast Asia current and proposed railways

A complete guide to train travel in Southeast Asia

European Rail Travel

Eurail Pass Travel Guide

About Nomadic Notes

About
Advertise
Contact
Contribute
Press/Media Mentions
Where I've Been

Search Nomadic Notes

Travel Notes

Travel Notes

Travel Resources

Digital Nomad Resources
Long-term Travel
Travel Blog Directory
Travel Gear
Travel Insurance
Travel Sites

Where To Stay In…

Bangkok
Chiang Mai
Da Nang
Ho Chi Minh City
Hoi An
Hong Kong
Jakarta
Kuala Lumpur
Macau
Penang
Singapore

Travel Newsletter

Sign up for the weekly travel newsletter for the latest posts and a roundup of best travel reads from around the web.

Copyright © 2023 Nomadic Notes · Site Map | Privacy · Log in